Expectations on service during PG&E PSPS?

Internet access discussion, including Fusion, IP Broadband, and Gigabit Fiber!
3 posts Page 1 of 1
by megabyte » Thu Jul 09, 2020 11:28 am
PG&E PSPS season is starting to approach. Despite having a backup power supply at my house, I did not have sonic.net service (broadband and voip) during outages last year. I also did not have cell service, leaving me completely without any easy ability to dial emergency services.

Back in the analog POTS day of access, phone service would still work during power outages. I've also experienced being able to continue having sonic.net service during lengthy unplanned power outages in the past.

I tried to get more clarification from support last year on what to expect during a planned power shutoff but wasn't able to get further clarification.

What should we be expecting with service during planned power shutoffs this year?
by dane » Thu Jul 09, 2020 11:58 am
The answer varies based upon the product available at your location. A high-level view:

Fusion Broadband+Phone service provides analog voice over copper lines and should operate indefinitely. The data service is xDSL from the central office and requires only that the premise router be powered. A small UPS can provide many hours of runtime, a large one can last a day or two.

Fusion Fiber service provides analog voice via an integrated telephone adaptor in the optical network terminal box at the customer home, which must be connected to power. The data service is also included - but for routing/WiFi, both the optical terminal and router/WiFi premise equipment will require on-site power. Again, a small UPS can be used, or larger one for more duration.

Fusion IP Broadband service provides analog voice via a standalone telephone adaptor, so all network devices on premise (modem/router/gateway, plus analog telephone adaptor) would require backup power on site. For the majority of sites, where the service is vDSL2 from a fiber-fed neighborhood node, that node also must have power. These sites have batteries that last 8-24 hours, but then a small local generator must be deployed. For sites where IP Broadband is delivered over fiber to the home, the central office side has backup power.

But what we saw during prior PSPS events was that it was impossible for AT&T to deploy and maintain generators at many of the remote node sites. As a result, some cabinets went offline during PSPS events. And this was particularly challenging near boundaries of PSPS events, where homes might still have power while their nearby equipment inside a PSPS zone went offline. Comcast also struggled with this, they simply don't own enough generators to power so much equipment, nor could they practially deploy enough to power everything, re-supply them with fuel, etc.

Comcast also made some good points about fire safety: an unattended generator can itself be a fire hazard and requires a huge clear fire-safe paved area around it, and those don't exist. As a result, when generators are needed, they generally use the ones on the utility trucks, and an employee sits in the truck and monitors everything for safety. They can then unplug when batteries are topped up and charge another site, or go obtain fuel for the generator. A single truck can manage a couple of locations like this. But, that won't work when the region is unsafe due to fire evacuation and is impractical on a large regional scale.

There has been a lot of pressure put on communications operators like AT&T and Comcast to expand backup power in their plant in response to the PSPS situation, but personally, I don't think that should be their responsibility. Reliable utility power has been available for decades, and the new normal of preventative shutoffs is a power utility problem, not a communications utility one. If power utilities now cannot provide reliable power, it should be their task to power essential equipment during the PSPS event. In other words, communications utilities should have power inputs on their devices for generator input, and PG&E should be the ones tasked with deploying a fleet of trucks to power essential utility loads when they must shut down their distribution grid.

But from Sonic's perspective, Fiber to the home service shows a unique advantage in this, generally having no active equipment in the outside plant environment.
Dane Jasper
Sonic
by megabyte » Fri Jul 10, 2020 10:47 am
Thanks for the reply and radical transparency! I've been trying to research as much as I can on what has changed since last year and now. It's good to hear FTTH offerings having unique advantages, unfortunately I'm not in area that has that offering yet.

For now, it looks like I'll plan for the same as last year!
3 posts Page 1 of 1

Who is online

In total there are 133 users online :: 1 registered, 0 hidden and 132 guests (based on users active over the past 5 minutes)
Most users ever online was 999 on Mon May 10, 2021 1:02 am

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 132 guests